Laminated Glass vs Toughened Glass: A Comprehensive Guide

Are you unsure whether to choose laminated or toughened glass for your next project? This guide is for homeowners, businesses, and anyone interested in learning about laminated and toughened glass. Whether you’re renovating your home, building a new office, or simply curious about different glass options, this information will be helpful.

Quick Comparison - Key Takeaways

Feature	Laminated Glass	Toughened Glass
Construction	Multiple glass layers with interlayer (e.g., PVB)	Single glass pane, heat-treated
Safety	Holds together when shattered	Breaks into small granules
Strength	Durable, but less strength than toughened glass	Very strong, resistant to physical force
Insulation	Excellent sound and UV insulation	Basic insulation properties
Applications	Car windshields, high-rise buildings	Shower doors, glass tables, oven windows
Alterations	Can be cut or drilled post-production	Must be cut to size before tempering

[ez-toc]

What is Laminated Glass?

Laminated glass, a type of safety glass, owes its name to its unique construction. It’s essentially made of two or more layers of glass bonded together with a plastic interlayer, typically polyvinyl butyral (PVB). The process of making laminated glass involves sandwiching the plastic layer between the glass layers, which are then subjected to heat and pressure. This results in a single piece of glass that, even when shattered, holds together due to the interlayer.

Key Features

Prevents shattering into sharp fragments, reducing injury risk.
Ideal for car windshields, high-rise buildings, and other safety-critical applications.
Dampens sound waves, improving acoustic comfort in buildings and vehicles.
Maintains a single sheet of glass even when broken, preventing pieces from falling out.
Resists wind, impact, and explosions better than standard glass.
Deters break-ins and vandalism by making entry more difficult.
Certain interlayers block harmful UV rays, protecting interiors from fading and sun damage.
Colored or patterned interlayers can be used for aesthetic purposes.
Can be combined with other glass types for enhanced properties like heat insulation or fire resistance.

What is Toughened Glass?

Toughened glass, also known as tempered glass, is another type of safety glass renowned for its strength and thermal resistance. It is made by heating a standard piece of glass to a very high temperature (around 620 degrees Celsius) and then rapidly cooling it, a process known as quenching. This process induces compressive stresses on the surface and strengthening forces in the interior, which dramatically increase the strength of the glass.

Key Features

Up to 5 times stronger than regular glass, resisting strong impacts and pressure.
Ideal for applications like shower doors, glass doors and tables, and oven windows.
Withstands high temperatures without cracking or warping, making it perfect for oven windows and cookware.
Shatters into small, blunt granules instead of sharp shards, minimizing injury risk.
Suitable for safety-critical applications like shower doors and high-traffic areas.
Pre-stressed during production, maintaining its strength even after breaking.
Resists scratches, chips, and wear and tear better than regular glass.
Smooth, non-porous surface simplifies cleaning and maintenance.
Can be combined with other glass types for additional features like insulation or tinting.
Sleek, minimalist appearance complements contemporary design styles.

Making the Decision: Laminated vs Toughened Glass

Making the right choice between laminated and toughened glass can feel like navigating a maze of options. While both offer significant advantages over standard glass, their unique strengths and limitations make them suitable for different situations. To help you navigate this decision, let’s delve deeper into their key features, alongside some additional factors to consider:

Strength & Durability

Toughened: Reigns supreme with 4-5x the strength of regular glass, ideal for high-impact areas like shower doors, tables, and oven windows.
Laminated: While not as strong, its multi-layer construction offers impressive durability. Even when broken, shards stick to the interlayer, minimizing injury risk.

Safety

Toughened: Shatters into small, blunt granules, reducing the risk of severe cuts compared to sharp shards.
Laminated: Holds together when broken, preventing dangerous shards from falling and promoting safety in critical areas like car windshields, buildings, and balustrades.

Insulation

Laminated: Shines in both energy efficiency and sound insulation thanks to the interlayer. Blocks UV rays and can be customized for enhanced insulation.
Toughened: Offers basic thermal insulation, but not as effective as laminated glass.

Additional Factors to Consider

Cost: Toughened glass is generally more affordable due to its simpler production process.
Appearance: Laminated glass offers customization with colored or patterned interlayers, while toughened glass has a clean, minimalist look.
Maintenance: Both are easy to clean, but laminated glass may require slightly more care for the interlayer.
Shape and Size: Toughened glass has limitations due to tempering, while laminated glass is more versatile.
Heat Treatment: Toughened glass cannot be further treated with heat, limiting its use. Laminated glass allows for additional treatments.
Special Features: Certain laminated types offer UV protection, blast resistance, or fire resistance. Toughened glass can be combined with films for added functionality.
Availability: Toughened glass is widely available, while laminated options may be limited based on thickness, interlayer type, and customization.

Remember When Choosing Glass:

Choose Toughened for maximum strength and impact resistance.
Choose Laminated for superior safety, security, and insulation.

Applications of Laminated and Toughened Glass

Laminated Glass Applications:

Safety-critical areas (windshields, buildings, skylights), security, and insulation.

A prime example of its application is in the Sydney Tower Eye, where laminated glass provides a secure and clear view of the city. The choice of laminated glass in this context provides safety without compromising the panoramic experience. Despite the high altitude and potential for extreme weather conditions, visitors can enjoy a clear and uninterrupted view with the assurance of their safety.

Sydney Tower Eye Laminated Glass — Laminated Glass was used in the construction of the Sydney Tower Eye

Toughened Glass Applications:

High-strength applications (shower doors, tables, balustrades, shopfronts).

A great example of this is the Zara store located on Pitt St in Sydney. The shopfront, made entirely of toughened glass, presents a sleek, modern aesthetic while providing exceptional durability and safety. Even if damaged, the glass would shatter into small, relatively harmless pieces, minimizing the risk to shoppers and pedestrians.

Zara store in Pitt St, Sydney using toughened glass — Zara store in Sydney CBD uses toughened glass for display windows

Choosing Between Laminated Glass & Toughened Glass

Ultimately, choosing between laminated and toughened glass depends on your specific needs and priorities. Consider the following factors:

Safety Requirements: If safety is paramount, laminated glass is preferable due to its ability to hold together when broken.
Sound and UV Insulation: Laminated glass excels in sound and UV insulation, making it ideal for noise-sensitive environments or areas exposed to strong sunlight.
Strength and Durability: If the glass will be subject to heavy physical impacts, toughened glass is a better choice due to its superior strength.
Post-Production Alterations: Laminated glass allows for cutting or drilling after production, while toughened glass requires these alterations before tempering.
Budget: Toughened glass generally costs less than laminated glass due to its simpler production process.

By carefully evaluating your needs and considering these factors, you can make an informed decision and choose the type of glass that best suits your project.

AUTHOR

Khalil Chahine

Khalil is the owner of Splendid Window Glass Repairs and has over 8 years experience as a glazier specialising in window glass repair, replacement and installations. Khalil takes great pride in his work and prides himself on providing an excellent service to all of his customers, no matter how big or small the job may be.